Has anyone seen Mastic/Oatmeal in person? Is it close to 05 Caramel?

I have heard the oatmeal is more yellow than sandstone which is more taupe.

I have heard this from 2 pple who have both seen oatmeal, one being the sa at balny.
 
melmac - which do you like better, mastic or sandstone? Would GH vs RH make a difference in your assessment?

P.S. Why is Balenciaga using the same color name again...and does this Mastic bear any resemblance to the original Mastic?
 
melmac - which do you like better, mastic or sandstone? Would GH vs RH make a difference in your assessment?

fiatflux-

I actually prefer the sandstone to mastic-- it is more taupey than yellow, and seems a bit more neutral to me. but this is maybe because i wear a lot of black, and i think taupe goes better. i think both are beautiful colors and i think with the GH they look even more similar. hope this helps!
 
cilla - i'm kind of a newbie -- so i really don't know if you can trust my opinion with the leather, but the bags i saw were kind of shiny. they looked more or less the same as the spring 07 (to me). again, i must stress i'm not an expert. sorry :confused1:
 
Can you post the pics?!?!? Please!?!? :yes:


Sorry this took so long;)
oatmealdayjpg.jpg

And here's my 05 Caramel. Similar????
P1020543.jpg