hmm... based on the wallets alone - I'm drawn to the metallic one, but I have a huge bias for metallic - I LOVE metallic.
However, somehow I feel like that particular metallic doesn't go as well with Damier as the second wallet. the bright leather on the inside I think would look FAB with damier! only saying cuz I "know" you as damier queen....
Perhaps Guccisima leather in a colour similar to the trim of the second wallet?