I have both. I am sending the 4 key holder back. My car key is too big to fit inside. If I add my extender/key ring to it, the car key hangs out from the bottom. After serious consideration, I decided ( for me ) that the whole point of having a key holder is to keep your keys tucked away, hidden and neat. My key was exposed, so I was getting the same result with the cles. So, for me, the holder didn't work ..but I know lots of TPF'er Love theirs and highly recommend them. The Vernis holder's are beautiful. I thought about keeping mine just to look at, but why waste it. :shame: So, I say the cles.