Cat: I must admit to owning 3 colors from the Pembrook collection..... plum, blue, and Bordeaux. All are in the Amelie style. And, I have a wine Amelie on order. (I couldn't resist an Overstock coupon on top of the sale price). After seeing a YT video of the wine Pembrook, I began to crave that color also. I know that my color selections are all from the same part of the rainbow.... but, that is what I love and use. Since I clearly don't need another handbag, anyone I buy needs to make me smile.
I love the look of the Claire style, but I know the flap top, with attached handle and logo lock would make the bag frustrating for me (personally) to use. Also, I think the size might be a tad too small for me. I have the Dooney large Elisa, which is slightly larger than the Claire and also has a flap opening (with an easier closure and fixed handles attached to the body of the bag) and I'm frustrated when I use the Elisa. I love the look, but functionally, it's not right for me.
But back to the colors of the Pembrook. If you tell me which color you are interested in I'll try to assess how the color looks IRL compared to what I see from the Dooney site and QVC site.