Yay or Nay on these bags??

When I first saw them I was thinking they might be a tad bit too plain for me too, but since now I am thinking that I might get the black one and tying a blue scarf onto it, then it would look more colorful.

I was thinking a blue scarf like the blue coach scarf pictured here:
98109_d2.jpg
 
Or would these scarves be better than the previous one for tying onto the black bag??

This one?
(pic from ebay) (ebay member raccugli)
a15c_1.JPG


This one??
(also pic from ebay) (ebay member raccugli)
0d8e_1.JPG
 
Congrats! Post pics when you get it! I've always thought that her bags look really nice in the catalog, so I'm curious to know how the quality is IRL. Let us know!

And I like the scarf!