I'd choose the BP. I think it's a gorgeous shade; however, I'm not sure how versatile it is. I think it would look fabulous with black, navy, cream, denim. Black will always be timeless and classic. It will most likely come down to your personal style. Do you prefer your bags to be neutral, or do you enjoy injecting color into your wardrobe with shoes/ bags? I make sure I have the classic neutrals in styles I love, then choose a beautiful, special color for my " pop" of color bag. For me, this color would be special. I will admit I carry the neutral bags 3/4 of the time. Good luck choosing. Let your instincts guide your decision.