okay, this is going to be long. i am in the same boat. i have the pochette metis in monogram canvas that i've owned for a few years. i love it. but i don't use it a lot. a crossbody doesn't suit me during the week because of work (i need a shoulder bag or tote). i usually save a crossbody for weekend errands or travel. that being said, i also just realized all of the bags on my wishlist are crossbodys LOL at first, i didn't know what to think of the reverse. i think i was actually relieved i didn't like it LOL but now with all of these youtube unboxings and instagram posts, it has grow on me and now i can't get it out of my head. so...that is my dilemma too. is it silly to have 2 of the same style since they're so similar? i do get what you're saying about the speedy's - i do that with the neverfull. i have 2 GMs and 2 MMs but damier and monogram so different. but i always tend to get different variations of something if i really love it so i'm personally leaning towards getting one. so if you really love the style and you use it regularly, then go for it. would you sell your monogram? i don't think i would. keep me posted what you decide to do!