I'm struggling with this now. I hate window coverings! I want the windows clutter-free all the time to expose the light and the views. However sometimes the sun is too bright.
I am dressing all the windows in the living areas in wood trim painted white. It really frames the views. Most of my windows currently have drywall around them except for the sill and skirt.
I want the windows to look taller, not wider. So I will probably avoid shutters.
My favorite right now is roller shades. I have had those in the living area for a few years and they hardly collect any dust. (I have dogs.) They look like fabric but wipe clean like a textured vinyl. They are not beautiful but they are nice enough since they are hardly ever showing.
However I really need blackout for the sun, and I love the idea of top down, bottom up shades so that I can choose where to block out the sun, but still have light flowing into the room. For example, one window is behind the TV and I need to block out the bottom of the window sometimes, but still want to see the sky views above. In the kitchen I may want privacy sometimes while I do dishes, but still have light coming in.
In the bedrooms, I love top down bottom up shades so that I can keep a square of window glass showing on top to let the view of the trees and light in. I can keep the bottom covered all the time for privacy. I have a top down bottom up cellular shade in there now with poly white sheers loosely draped around the top and sides. The sheer material stays remarkably clean and dust free, and can be washed. I let it puddle at the bottom. It makes me feel like I am in the Caribbean.
However cellular shades are not my favorite, especially for living areas, and I feel like they are fragile and get dusty. That may not be the case, but I wonder if there are other options for top down bottom up.
And to complicate all of this, I plan to replace all the windows in the next 6-7 years, so I'm not sure how much sill depth I will have. I really want the window coverings to be inset. With the low e glass, I'm not sure I would have the sun glare problem in the living area anyway.
Also love roman shades, but they seem like they would be dusty. I just took down fabric valances that were dusty and I really just want to throw them out.
So I am going to try to hold off as long as I can and commit to window coverings after all the windows are replaced. I may have to get something temporary in the meantime, hopefully not. Apparently I paid $177 in 2010 for the roller shade I took out to trim the living room window, and It doesn't fit anymore. I made a wood valance to hide the hardware, but when I replace the window, I'll lose depth so I may have to remake the valance then anyway. It's all very frustrating.
Hopefully I won't have to install a window covering for the new patio door. It's too pretty to cover! I'm hoping the low e glass eliminates any glaring sun issues.