Leah - you're right that it really is dependent on many factors including location, first time buyer, etc. I guess I was just seeing a surge in interest for the Kelly which made me resurrect this thread. And Quelle is right, the Birkin has become very ubiquitous because of the fanfare associated with certain celebrities while the Kelly is still sort of "under the radar". I say that loosely because the Kelly has surged in popularity but it hasn't hit "mainstream popularity" the way the Birkin has.