Which would be the BEST BLACK BAG ???

Which one would you chose ???

  • Balenciaga black "day"

  • Balenciaga black "city"

  • Mulberry black Bayswater

  • Chloé black quilted Bay

  • Chloé black non quilted Bay

  • Other, please suggest...


Results are only viewable after voting.

catcat

O.G.
Sep 6, 2006
5,613
36
South of France
This is rather a long shot since all my spare money goes into our summervaccation for now but this fall I really need/want a new black bag.
I have a few on my mind but wanted to see which ones you guys would prefer.:yes:

Balenciaga black "city"
Balenciaga black "day"
Mulberry black Bayswater
Chloé black quilted Bay
Chloé black nonquilted Bay

or other???

I want a practical everyday bag that can hold at least as much as the "city" and that can if needed be shouldercarried quite comfortably.
 

pseub

Bonne vivante
O.G.
Oct 24, 2005
4,036
7
Los Angeles
www.unefemme.net
I voted for the City in black. It's a great size for every day.

Also would suggest the Hayden Harnett Triple Strap Satchel. I have that one in black and it's a really cool bag.
 

pixiechic

So thankful.
O.G.
Apr 20, 2006
4,128
121
Denver
From your list, I'd say either the City or the Mulberry Bayswater. Chloe is some heavy stuff!

Not to be too much of a pseub echo :P, but you may want to take a look at Hayden-Harnett. The Hudson Triple Strap she mentioned is almost exactly the same size as the City, but lots less expensive. I have a HH black Havana Hobo and it is my one perfect big black bag.
 

absolutanne

Level: purse peace!!!
O.G.
Jul 22, 2006
1,661
154
I voted 'other' only because I've found my definition of the perfect black bag:
The Gerard Darel Charlotte/ 24 heures bag...!


It can be carried on the shoulder or by the crook of your arm. I got it for $369 (much cheaper than the other options listed above!)
I dont own any balenciaga or chloe or mulberry, so i cannot judge them.
 

Berlyn

<3 H
May 24, 2007
1,333
0
I voted City! I am getting that next, I'm hooked since I got my part-time.
 

PinkSuadeSoho

Princess Grace Ave
O.G.
Jul 17, 2006
9,420
3
Spain & France
I just bought a Balenciaga Black City and the leather is TDF! You can't go wrong especially if this is the first B bag in your collection. Beware of the addiction factor!!!!!
 

Kimmi

Member
Aug 6, 2006
3,874
2
They are all nice bags, I don't think you could go wrong with any one of then. Personally I love the Bayswater, but the City is a really close second.
 

Oh Donna!

Member
Sep 8, 2006
4,052
1
Soon the UK!
I just got a Michael Kors black leather Joplin bag. It is by far THE nicest bag I have ever owned. The workmanship is perfect and its absolutely gorgeous. The leather is thick and soft and I love the hardware on it. AND it was under $500 with shipping. I got it on bloomingdales.com. They have it pictured in the fatique color. I just ordered that one this morning. I am so in love with this bag.

Just hoping my daughter doesnt borrow it, I may never get it back!
 
Sep 14, 2006
2,131
5
San Francisco
i vote for either city or quilted bay!
and what about Chanel?
do you like cabas, baby cabas, or maybe GST or flap?LOL could you tell that i love Chanel...

but i also love city!