Which would be the BEST BLACK BAG ???

Which one would you chose ???

  • Balenciaga black "day"

  • Balenciaga black "city"

  • Mulberry black Bayswater

  • Chloé black quilted Bay

  • Chloé black non quilted Bay

  • Other, please suggest...


Results are only viewable after voting.

catcat

O.G.
Sep 6, 2006
5,613
36
South of France
This is rather a long shot since all my spare money goes into our summervaccation for now but this fall I really need/want a new black bag.
I have a few on my mind but wanted to see which ones you guys would prefer.:yes:

Balenciaga black "city"
Balenciaga black "day"
Mulberry black Bayswater
Chloé black quilted Bay
Chloé black nonquilted Bay

or other???

I want a practical everyday bag that can hold at least as much as the "city" and that can if needed be shouldercarried quite comfortably.
 

pseub

Bonne vivante
O.G.
Oct 24, 2005
4,036
7
Los Angeles
www.unefemme.net
I voted for the City in black. It's a great size for every day.

Also would suggest the Hayden Harnett Triple Strap Satchel. I have that one in black and it's a really cool bag.
 

pixiechic

So thankful.
O.G.
Apr 20, 2006
4,127
114
Lenox & Phipps
From your list, I'd say either the City or the Mulberry Bayswater. Chloe is some heavy stuff!

Not to be too much of a pseub echo :P, but you may want to take a look at Hayden-Harnett. The Hudson Triple Strap she mentioned is almost exactly the same size as the City, but lots less expensive. I have a HH black Havana Hobo and it is my one perfect big black bag.
 

absolutanne

Level: purse peace!!!
O.G.
Jul 22, 2006
1,660
136
I voted 'other' only because I've found my definition of the perfect black bag:
The Gerard Darel Charlotte/ 24 heures bag...!


It can be carried on the shoulder or by the crook of your arm. I got it for $369 (much cheaper than the other options listed above!)
I dont own any balenciaga or chloe or mulberry, so i cannot judge them.
 

Berlyn

<3 H
May 24, 2007
1,333
0
I voted City! I am getting that next, I'm hooked since I got my part-time.
 

PinkSuadeSoho

Princess Grace Ave
O.G.
Jul 17, 2006
9,420
2
Spain & France
I just bought a Balenciaga Black City and the leather is TDF! You can't go wrong especially if this is the first B bag in your collection. Beware of the addiction factor!!!!!
 

Kimmi

Member
Aug 6, 2006
3,874
2
They are all nice bags, I don't think you could go wrong with any one of then. Personally I love the Bayswater, but the City is a really close second.
 

Oh Donna!

Member
Sep 8, 2006
4,052
0
Soon the UK!
I just got a Michael Kors black leather Joplin bag. It is by far THE nicest bag I have ever owned. The workmanship is perfect and its absolutely gorgeous. The leather is thick and soft and I love the hardware on it. AND it was under $500 with shipping. I got it on bloomingdales.com. They have it pictured in the fatique color. I just ordered that one this morning. I am so in love with this bag.

Just hoping my daughter doesnt borrow it, I may never get it back!
 
Sep 14, 2006
2,130
4
San Francisco
i vote for either city or quilted bay!
and what about Chanel?
do you like cabas, baby cabas, or maybe GST or flap?LOL could you tell that i love Chanel...

but i also love city!