My Vacanze has had the most compliments recently, probably because I wore it all winter. I'm still wearing it, in fact. I should replace it with a new style, but Tokis are scarce at the moment (with the exception of eBay... *shudder*)
Before the Toki craze (1-2 yrs ago), I did get heaps of compliments on my Toki bags because the prints were eyecatchingly cute. The Tan playground, Inferno, and Paradiso get the most compliments in that order, whichever the style.