Which to choose 07 Black GGH PT or CITY?

Whick bag I should hold on to?

  • 07 Black GGH PT

  • 07 Black GGH CITY


Results are only viewable after voting.

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Aarponen

Proud & Preowned
O.G.
Apr 8, 2008
1,657
29
Ok girls, my husband went mad at me having 2 Bbags too similar in style, same colour. The whole row started as I was buying tomato GSH PT last night and things got heated, as I have Tomato GSH city already. I was not allowed to buy it, :sad: Then the discussion continued into the black couple. I can have as many Bbags I want as long as every single one is different colour.

I need help- how to explain the difference of the bags to my husband, so I could keep both or how to choose which one to keep. They both are gorgeous, but which one would you choose? I love them equally...
 
Ha! Your husband sounds a little like mine. He doesnt make me choose but sometimes questions why I would have 2 of the exact same leather (then I go into my rant about different styles working for different situations and he gets a glazed look on his face and then leaves me alone):nuts:

I personally love the PT above the city because the style works better on me. And IMHO, the GH looks so stunning on the PT. But if you love both, explain to him the subtle differences in the 2 and then add in that Bal leather and their styles are so timeless (I told mine I plan to keep mine until I am old and grey, so that helped ease his mind).

Plus, we can always use more than one black bag! What woman has only one pair of black shoes in her wardrobe? Same goes for bags!
 
Just about all my bags are black and my DH says that they all look the same even when the are different Prada, Chanel etc :smile: My first BLACK bbag will be here this week. I'm so excited.
 
Thanks Susan Lee, I guess my hubby wants me to get reasonable... I got so many bags last month I lost count, and so he thinks that maybe it would be better to decrease the duplicates and concentrate on one style and various colours eg. stop spending so much money. I have to agree with him though, I sort of went with the flow and bought bought bought.... Thanks for your contribution.
 
Oh, Luvprada, you have to do a reveal for us when your Bbag arrives!
and Aalinne, thanks for contribution, I am starting to lean on towards city though, as I have such a collection and maybe I will stick to my cities :sad: even it makes me so sad.
 
My hubby wants me to be the same way-I totally understand your dilema! I am always sad to lose a bag. That being said I have sold off most of my other designers and kept my bags that I know I will keep forever (my Bals and my Chloes).

I do hope whatever decision you make will be relatively painless :flowers:
 
I think you should keep whatever works for you, like your clothes etc. I saw your "collection thread" and thought you really wear the city really nice!!! So maybe you should keep the city? Well or you can keep the one with better leather!! that's always an approach!
 
I love the city much more than the PT so my vote goes to the city.

I more or less agree with your husband regarding the SGH Tomato City and PT being too similar but I agree with you that when you love a color, there is nothing wrong with having it in different styles. My own collection includes the same color in different styles (like Anthra SGH Midday and SGH City / Plomb SGH City and SGH Brief / Vert Thyme SGH Brief, SGH PT, and SGH Day). When I love a color I try to collect them in styles that are different shapes.
 
Don't feel bad.My hubby was the same way until I broke things down.He loves the look of these bags and thats a first for him.He's never paid attention to any of my bags until I showed him Balenciaga.Just break things down to him.I wish mine would say I could have as many as I want.Your a lucky girl!Oh Yeah and i'd go for the City!
 
Last edited: