Which Three Stone Ring

[marialc121]

Hi Everyone. Just wanted to get your input on what design I should go with. The center stone will be an oval and I initially liked the pear sides but then I saw the oval sides and now I can’t decide which one. Thanks in advance for your feedback!

 

[A bottle of Red]

Love the pears

 

[lill_canele]

Oval with the pear sides looks quite cute and a bit younger looking.

Oval with the oval sides looks much more mature and traditional.

Just my first impressions though.

If I had to seriously consider, I'd go with pear sides. I like a bit of variety.

Have you tried them on the finger you intend to wear them on? Maybe do that and take photos.
Sometimes it's the look of the ring when it's on your finger that will help you decide what looks best.

 

[QuelleFromage]

The pears direct attention more to the center stone.
The ovals are more a full-on three stone ring. You will also notice it more if the oval side stones are not as good as the center stone. It's hard to tell from the photo but they look to be a different color.

If you try them on I think you will know, because they are going to look very different on the hand.

 

[marialc121]

Oval with the pear sides looks quite cute and a bit younger looking.

Oval with the oval sides looks much more mature and traditional.

Just my first impressions though.

If I had to seriously consider, I'd go with pear sides. I like a bit of variety.

Have you tried them on the finger you intend to wear them on? Maybe do that and take photos.
Sometimes it's the look of the ring when it's on your finger that will help you decide what looks best.

No, I have not tried them on. Unfortunately, I won’t be able to. I’m leaning towards the pears side stone as it looks more feminine and highlights the oval but on the other hand, I don’t want it to take away the attention of my engagement ring (this will be a right hand ring)

 

[marialc121]

The pears direct attention more to the center stone.
The ovals are more a full-on three stone ring. You will also notice it more if the oval side stones are not as good as the center stone. It's hard to tell from the photo but they look to be a different color.

If you try them on I think you will know, because they are going to look very different on the hand.

Thank you for your input! The photos are just stock photos and not the diamonds that will be used. Unfortunately, I won’t be able to try them before purchasing so I have to go with which setting I like most.

 

[Swanky]

I voted but didn't know it was for the right hand, they look like e-rings to me, sorry!
I change to all same shape for right hand, although I don't prefer it. Just seems slightly less e-ring-ish

 

[DS2006]

Ahhh, I, too, assumed it was an engagement ring! The oval with pear sides definitely looks like an engagement ring. So I'd vote for the 3 ovals for a right hand ring. I think your poll won't mean much since I think most assumed it was an engagement ring.

 

[marialc121]

I voted but didn't know it was for the right hand, they look like e-rings to me, sorry!
I change to all same shape for right hand, although I don't prefer it. Just seems slightly less e-ring-ish

No worries! Thanks for your feedback. I wanted a three stone ring because I wanted something that represented our family of three (and I’ve always wanted a three stone ring). I’m glad to hear feedback on which style looks better because I’m more concerned about the design over it looking like an engagement ring.

 

[livethelake]

I love the Oval with the oval side stones. Something about the symmetry of it feels right. I think it's sophisticated and very modern despite being a classic look.

 

[marialc121]

Ahhh, I, too, assumed it was an engagement ring! The oval with pear sides definitely looks like an engagement ring. So I'd vote for the 3 ovals for a right hand ring. I think your poll won't mean much since I think most assumed it was an engagement ring.

No problem. I love any feedback. I’m not opposed to it looking like an engagement ring so any input is appreciated!

 

[QuelleFromage]

For right hand I too vote three oval stones; also knowing that it represents your family.