i like the regular speedy infinately better. i think it is a true classic and will never go out of style or date itself. whenever i see the perforated speedy i think marc jacobs got a little too excited with the office supplies...
i like the regular one too.it is a classic. the perforated is nice, but you may be taking a chance if it does not do well. but ultimately what matter, is how you feel about the bag. you have to truly love it.
I'm not a big fan of the perforated line either. I saw it IRL and it just didn't appeal to me. *Blah*
I vote for the regular Mono Speedy which is a classic. I love mine. You can also get a Speedy Damier