I'm not sure which Maggie you have, the coach print fabric or a leather one, but I still prefer the LV! I think the NF is the perfect casual bag, you can keep it uncinched to be really casual and carry lots of stuff, or cinch it in for days and evenings out. I don't think the LV Neverfull is too fancy at all! Good luck with your decision!
I posted on the Coach forum also to get an even perspective.... ugh... hard decision!! I like both! If I keep the Neverfull, it's expensive. If I keep the Coach, it's cheaper and I don't feel so bad to use it daily.
well im a die hard coachie for the most part but i find the maggie to fall off the shoulders too much its annoying. the neverfull is a cute bag but the straps are a bit thin. between the two i guess id pick the neverfull. or you could also get a coach leather madison carryall. its kind of more "totey" lol.