Which should I keep? Gucci Disco or Chloe Mini Marcie?

[lvfanaddict]

I feel like these two bags are a little too much alike. Which would you keep and why? Thanks!

 

[inginga]

IMO Disco looks better in black than Marcie and is more versatile - I would keep Gucci. I have black Disco and Mini Marcie in Pistachio - first one gets more use in fall/winter, Marcie - in summer.

 

[mkr]

The disco will be easy to get in and out of. I'm not a fan of flap bags for that reason. The Marcie's two colored stitching doesn't appeal to me.

 

[Johnpauliegal]

They are both lovely bags; however I'm more partial to the Gucci disco bag.
Good luck in your decision.

 

[lms910]

I had the same dilemma and chose the Disco!

 

[Indiana]

I guess most of us on here would pick the Disco but if you posted on the Chloe forum, you may get the opposite response Lol!

 

[snibor]

I guess most of us on here would pick the Disco but if you posted on the Chloe forum, you may get the opposite response Lol!

Agreed!

My vote disco. A classic bag that should look good for years. Not so sure the Chloe wouldn't feel dated in years to come. But both bags are beautiful.

 

[Venessa84]

In black, I prefer the disco. If the Marcie was another color, I may have actually picked that one.

 

[Lavidacolor]

Disco! I have a large Marcie and think it looks better in other colors besides black.

 

[andrea.nicole]

I prefer the Disco based on the security I would always question with the Marcie. I have to have a zipper.

 

[applecidered]

Definitely disco. I am not a fan of flap bags and how to get into them.

 

[SugahSweetTee]

I guess I'm the lone dissenter. I like the Marcie better overall.