Which should I buy; YSL or Celine pre-owned Boot?

[snick7341]

I'm trying to decide between two pairs of pre-owned boots; both size 38. I've tried on recent YSL boots and 38 is the right size. I'm a 38 in Jimmy Choo and 7.5-8 in Stuart Wietzman boots and have a narrow foot. I also am looking at these Celine boots in a 38 but haven't tried on Celine before. Thoughts between these two?

NEW Celine Hedi Slimane Boots 38, US 7

Shop mmarlay's closet or find the perfect look from millions of stylists. Fast shipping and buyer protection. Beautiful never worn boots

poshmark.com

YSL Classic Black Bootie

Shop maehess's closet or find the perfect look from millions of stylists. Fast shipping and buyer protection. These boots are very lightly worn (max 4 x) and are in like new condition. Price half of what I paid with shipping and tax. They are a size 38 Italian (8) and are a beautiful classic...

poshmark.com

Any feedback appreciated, thanks!

 

[luiza]

I like Celine more.

 

[randr21]

I have a pair of black pumps from new celine and they ran slightly big on me. I own lots of YSL and prefer their shoes.

They are both very similar. Personally, I'd go with YSL bc I like the elongated toe shape better as it's more slimming. It also looks narrower than the. Celine, which may fit your feet better? Doesnt hurt to save a few hundred bucks too with YSL.