Which rose gold Elsa Peretti necklace looks nicer on me?

[StarBrite310]

I have been looking for a classic rose gold necklace that works well on my skin tone. Most I've tried blend right in with my coloring but I realized I needed a thicker more substantial piece such as these. I wear yellow gold everyday and would love some variety. My boyfriend said he would buy me a Tiffany necklace for Christmas but I still can't decide which looks nicer, although I am leaning toward the tear drop. I have an old sterling silver bean from 15 years ago or so and it seems as if that one looks more like a bean than this newer RG version. Am I crazy? lol.

Anyway this is the 12mm tear drop and the 9mm bean. I tried the 12mm bean but I felt it was too big in that shape and looked less a bean than the 9mm size. Does anyone have both the tear drop and bean and wear one more than the other?

Thanks for the help

 

[MatAllston]

I prefer the tear drop on you as it is more substantial. I prefer the bean in 12mm.

 

[Violet Bleu]

Go with the tear drop! It looks beautiful! You already have a bean anyways. 😊

 

[LizO...]

i prefer the tear drop on you as it is more substantial. I prefer the bean in 12mm.

+1

 

[AntiqueShopper]

I prefer the tear drop on you as it is more substantial. I prefer the bean in 12mm.

100% agree!

 

[auberielle]

Tear drop looks amazing!

 

[emchhardy]

Tear drop - no brainer - looks perfect.

 

[Canturi lover]

I prefer the bean 😊

 

[StarBrite310]

I really appreciate everyone's opinions. When I wrote this thread I was having my sterling silver bean cleaned as I have not worn it in probably 12-15 years (lol seriously, just not fond of ss anymore), but I got it back today and actually it's bigger than the RG 9mm. I guess it's the 12mm but I never realized it. To me it was always just a small bean. I do agree that that larger size looks better now.

 

[staceyjan]

I saw the tear drop today and did a double take as I did not realize what it was at first glance but my first thought was it did remind me of a bean. Maybe I am a minority with this one but thinking a tear drop would symbolize mourning and not a celebration with BF. JMHO.

 

[NurseAnn]

I prefer the bean in any size over the tear drop both in aesthetic and symbolism.

 

[katrice9000]

Bean for reasons stated

 

[Laila619]

I think they are both pretty, but the tear drop looks a little nicer IMO.

 

[Storm Spirit]

Going by the pics, I prefer the teardrop, but IMO it depends on the neckline of the top.

 

[darkangel07760]

I have been looking for a classic rose gold necklace that works well on my skin tone. Most I've tried blend right in with my coloring but I realized I needed a thicker more substantial piece such as these. I wear yellow gold everyday and would love some variety. My boyfriend said he would buy me a Tiffany necklace for Christmas but I still can't decide which looks nicer, although I am leaning toward the tear drop. I have an old sterling silver bean from 15 years ago or so and it seems as if that one looks more like a bean than this newer RG version. Am I crazy? lol.

Anyway this is the 12mm tear drop and the 9mm bean. I tried the 12mm bean but I felt it was too big in that shape and looked less a bean than the 9mm size. Does anyone have both the tear drop and bean and wear one more than the other?

Thanks for the help

I prefer the teardrop on you