Which RED coat??

  1. Hi! Ok, I have another dilema. I am being quite indecisive again with something.

    These two red coats are cute but I can't seem to figure out which one I should get.

    Coat 1 is from A/X. It's alot thicker than Coat 2
    Coat 2 is from Gap. I like it's classic shape.

    So, which one?? I've also attached pics of me with coat 2 since I bought it today.

    Coat 1: http://www.armaniexchange.com/product/womens/all+sale/classic+wool+pea+coat.do

    Coat 2: http://www.gap.com/browse/product.do?cid=6951&pid=522661
    Photo 8.jpg Photo 9.jpg Photo 10.jpg
  2. My vote goes for the Armani Exchange coat because it's a feminine twist on a classic peacoat. Plus, I think it has cuter details (collar, pockets) than the GAP one.
  3. The AX is cuter but the Gap seems more functional. I would probably buy the AX
  4. i like the a/x one more too
  5. i think the gap one looks very good on you
  6. Ugh I bought that Gap one a few weeks ago and they lady said they didn't have red so I got black! grr. I like the Gap one. It's really comfortable.
  7. The Gap one...It looks fantastic on you! Not a fan of the AX one
  8. OOPs.. sorry guys. The picture of me is with COat1 . the AX coat.
  9. Thaks for the input everyone =) BTW, since I've posted this thread last night, the AX coat is already gone from their website! Crazy. I wanted to get a size S instead of the M too.

    I think I will stick with the AX. It's thick and warm =)