I personally prefer the second one. The first one is the bowler and it is a little smaller than the 2nd one. I am not sure if it can be carried on the shoulder as it has slightly shorter handles. It also does not have the zippered pocket on the back (from what I recall). The other one is the shoulder bay, it has better proportion and can be easily carried on the shoulder. It also has the additional zippered pocket on the back (not quilted). Either one, they are both beautiful. Good Luck!