Which purple bag would you choose?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

seashell11

seashell11

O.G.
Nov 14, 2011
67
0
#1
I have decided that I need to add some color to my collection and purple was the winner of my personal debate (though teal/aegean was a close second and will probably be next). I don't see any in the current collection that I love, so I have been looking on the Bay. I have found a few that I like and now I can't decide. These styles have all been around for awhile, so I'm wondering if any of you ladies have/had them and have any opinions for or against each.

The contenders are:

- Hailey (14304) in plum
- Alexandra (FP version, 15273) in aubergine (at least that's what they're calling it)
- Kristin hobo (14783) in raisin
- Soho satchel (12688) in purple patent

I already have a Hailey in mahogany and an MFF Alexandra in black and love both of them. I also have a Kristin hippie and another style of Kristin hobo and love both of those too. This is gonna be a hard decision. It may just come down to which one I can get the best deal on, but is there anything else I should consider? Any issues with the various leathers or hardware? Thanks for any and all help!!
 
Last edited:
#2
I Love Both The Hailey & Alexandra!

seashell11 said:
I have decided that I need to add some color to my collection and purple was the winner of my personal debate (though teal/aegean was a close second and will probably be next). I don't see any in the current collection that I love, so I have been looking on the Bay. I have found a few that I like and now I can't decide. These styles have all been around for awhile, so I'm wondering if any of you ladies have/had them and have any opinions for or against each.

The contenders are:

- Hailey (14304) in plum
- Alexandra (FP version, 15273) in aubergine (at least that's what they're calling it)
- Kristin hobo (14783) in raisin
- Soho satchel (12688) in purple patent

I already have a Hailey in mahogany and an MFF Alexandra in black and love both of them. I also have a Kristin hippie and another style of Kristin hobo and love both of those too. This gonna be a hard decision. It may just come down to which one I can get the best deal on, but is there anything else I should consider? Any issues with the various leathers or hardware? Thanks for any and all help!!
Click to expand...
 
#3
Soho Satchel! Especially if you've already got versions of the other styles. I just love the purple shade in that season's Sohos and Coach just doesn't make that kind of patent anymore (I dislike the current smooth patent).
 
#4
Keep in mind that the jade Hailey is to die for, so if you are planning on getting a teal color next, you might not want to get a plum Hailey, unless it is fine with you to have a bunch of Haileys.

I like all of your choices so I would get the one that you could get the best deal on. You should make sure you can deal with all the sections in the Soho satchel.
 
#5
I have the Kristin hobo in raisin and the Hailey in plum ( and many many many more purple bags!!! Love the purples that Coach makes!).....and I love them both...the Soho satchel would be my personal last choice...have you thought about the Lindsey in the patent? I have last year's purple in that patent but I know there is a newer more shimmery purple patent in the Lindsey this year....
 
#6
timetoshop2012 said:
I Love Both The Hailey & Alexandra!
Click to expand...

Me too! I always wonder, though, if I'm missing something else great. But there is definitely wisdom in sticking with what works!

ozmodiar said:
Soho Satchel! Especially if you've already got versions of the other styles. I just love the purple shade in that season's Sohos and Coach just doesn't make that kind of patent anymore (I dislike the current smooth patent).
Click to expand...

I didn't think that I wanted patent (I think it's beautiful, just not my style), but that one jumped out at me and I love it!

whateve said:
Keep in mind that the jade Hailey is to die for, so if you are planning on getting a teal color next, you might not want to get a plum Hailey, unless it is fine with you to have a bunch of Haileys.

I like all of your choices so I would get the one that you could get the best deal on. You should make sure you can deal with all the sections in the Soho satchel.
Click to expand...

Good point about the jade Hailey...that one is fabulous! I wouldn't mind too much having 3 Haileys though. The sections on the Soho satchel is really the only thing making me hesitate on that one.

scootscoach said:
I have the Kristin hobo in raisin and the Hailey in plum ( and many many many more purple bags!!! Love the purples that Coach makes!).....and I love them both...the Soho satchel would be my personal last choice...have you thought about the Lindsey in the patent? I have last year's purple in that patent but I know there is a newer more shimmery purple patent in the Lindsey this year....
Click to expand...

I really should look into the Lindsey. My most favorite bag is my large Sophia. I just don't know if I like the N/S style as much.

Thank you for all the advice and ideas! We'll see what I end up with. :)
 
#7
seashell11 said:
I really should look into the Lindsey. My most favorite bag is my large Sophia. I just don't know if I like the N/S style as much.

Thank you for all the advice and ideas! We'll see what I end up with. :)
Click to expand...

Mine too. I hated Lindsey when I first saw it but she really grew on me! Beliee it or not, when she's carried she really doesn't look as north/south as she does when empty.
 
#8
Great choices!!!!
I love the Raisin color of the Kristin Hobo but I find it difficult to get in and out of the Hobo. (I have the Python Kristin Hobo)
I love the style of the Alexandra. I would love to see the color.
I say get the Alexandra!!!!

Lynne :D
 
#11
I have the plum Hailey and also think its a great bag! I have several Kristin hobos (although not a raisin one) and this is a super comfy style. I think it depends on which size bag you prefer and how much you'll be carrying. Hailey is deceptively roomy!
 
#14
I have the large Kristin Hobo in Raisin and love it!! The color is gorgeous, the leather is soft and smooshy, and I love the slouch when carrying her. It's a bag that always gets compliments when I carry it. Here's a pic:
 
#15
I can vouch for the Alexandra in Berry. It's a true plum purple that leans a bit toward pink. Great neutral, goes with just about anything. I love the bag for traveling because it's convertible. You can get a satchel look, a hobo look, or long shoulder bag look with one bag. I carry it most often as a satchel, by the short handles. Here it is in action:
IMG-20120810-00290.jpg
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top