Which Orange? Kelly vs Birkin

[bornfree]

Given that orange is such a bright hermes color - which will you choose?

1. 35 orange retourne clemence kelly PHW OR
2. 30 orange togo birkin GHW

i personally love the chic-ness of carrying a kelly esply with the strap. But am concerned if a 35cm kelly may look too loud/big in orange? On the other hand, do you feel that a 30cm birkin in orange is like having a loud casual color in a smaller dressier size?

Which will you choose? Will be great if you can post some pics of yours too!

 

[ms.louboutin]

birkin just because i prefer birkins! but another good point is that kelly is more classic and orange wouldnt be the best on a kelly as a birkin, birkin is more casual and it would look gorgeous in togo with gold hardware

 

[irishlass1029]

The So Kelly in orange is another alternative, too - it looks LUSCIOUS in orange!

 

[irishlass1029]

I stole this pic of geminisparkles from the action thread. It's a 22 cm So Kelly!

 

[bornfree]

thanks irishlass1029 for posting the pics here. Yeah GS certainly look hot here!
ms. louboutin - but do you tik tt orange on birkin will look nicer in a 35 instead of a 30?

 

[irishlass1029]

BTW, I voted for the Birkin - I just think the Kelly is too dressy for me to want one in orange. I have seen some who can rock it, though - just not for me...and I am a 30cm gal, myself. Not that I HAVE a birkin yet - LOL! But it will be a 30 cm when...

 

[costa]

what color were you thinking of? POitron or the brighter orange?
I voted for birkin thinking of the brighter one, but if it' poitron, definitely the kelly!

 

[bornfree]

costa - its the brighter orange

 

[Poshhoney]

Birkin certainly. For me the Kelly is too clasically formal- looking to pull off in orange.
35 b rocks hehe *off to find pics*

 

[Sammyjoe]

I voted for a birkin. Good luck with whatever you decide

 

[mooks]

While I'm a HUGE Birkin fan I love seeing a Kelly in a bright colour especially in 35 so that's what I voted for

 

[IFFAH]

30 orange birkin gh because it's in GHW.

 

[lulilu]

I love 35 kellys in bright colors. I have one in BJ and IMO it does look big or as big as my 35 birkins because it is narrower etc.

 

[purselust]

for ref i think orange 35 birkin GHW is drop-dead-gorgeous!

 

[LQYB]

I have a 28 orange kelly and honestly that's it. that's all I can handle.

So go to the birkin!