Which one?

[areyoulistening]

Hello! I don't post often, but I love lurking. So I'm not new, but new. Haha. Anyway, I'm 31, single, plus size.. (I say this for reference for age, status, and size appropriateness.) And I really love the bean pendant and the open heart pendant. Both mini sizes. I intend on getting one in silver, but I just don't know which! I like small, dainty necklaces so the sizes would be either a 11mm open heart pendant on a lengthened 20 inch chain or a 9mm bean on a lengthened 18 inch chain. Help me decide?

 

[MatAllston]

I say the bean because the mini or small open heart would flip a lot.

 

[StarBrite310]

I much prefer the bean to the open heart and this is coming from someone who has both.

 

[DiamondsForever]

I say Bean too as you don't see as many of them, and they're super cute.

 

[areyoulistening]

Thank you all! My mom liked the bean, too. I think that's what I'm going with!

 

[emchhardy]

I don't think you can go wrong with either one. I would try them both on and see which one you like better.

 

[Susan45]

I also own them both and would choose the bean.

 

[Saywhatyouwant]

My vote is the bean.

 

[staceyjan]

I am also plus size - size 1x and have the large heart on a wider chain (almost looks like the mesh chain) from many years ago, the silver hearts with the gold heart in the middle and the bean on the wire necklace.

With that being said, I think the bean is original and unique. The large heart does flap around and it is scratched. But, I would try both on and see what looks and feels the best. Both are classic pieces.

 

[Winston3043]

I've worn the open heart (silver with a diamond) since ~2007 and it still looks great [emoji4] Love the bean necklace as well, but I can't imagine being happier with a necklace than I am with my open heart one

 

[LVoeletters]

Heart!

 

[areyoulistening]

Thank you all!

I completely did a 360, and ordered the heart key pendant in mini and a 30 inch small beaded chain. I don't know what it was, but it just caught me and I felt like I "needed" it. I'll probably end up with the bean and the open heart pendant at some time, too.

 

[Susan45]

I have a small heart key pendant in rose gold and I love it. I think you will be happy with it.

 

[areyoulistening]

I found a wonderful deal on a medium open heart pendant and couldn't pass it up. I'd have preferred the small (originally wanted the mini, but it may be too small) but this one is growing on me. I'll definitely be getting the bean in the near future!

Thank you all.