Which one?
- Thread starter Khaleesicat
- Start date
TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
All 3 are gorgeous, if you can afford them all get them and if you later decide you don’t like one of them you can return, this whole rouge discontinuing situation is making me nervous, for months I have wanted the ysl small black Loulou but haven’t been able to purchase because of price and now that I just discovered the rouge thanks to YouTube and I been thinking it would be a great alternative to the Loulou quality wise,is getting discontinued, I have the 25 black in my cart but since I haven’t seen it in person I just can’t decide:/
I’m having the hardest time making a decision. The black seems most practical. But I’ve always been in love with tea roses. I think I’m panicking as well since they are discontinuing the rogue.
I prefer the navy with rivets, it’s timeless and classy but... the tea rose is beautiful too. The black, I’m not keen on as you can get many beautiful black bags. I’m not really helping after all. Lol. I’m very indecisive in general too.
if i would feel comfortable carrying the tea rose, i'd get it in a heartbeat. the price right now is great too, i say get the tea rose!!
There is really no need to panick. The Rogue will not just disappear. This is what Coach does. It "discontinues." Then, with Coach's history, its bags always miraculously reappear, whether in the Outlets or other sites. Even its Rogues that are now "sold out" online can be found in stores.
Khaleesicat, we seem to have an identical problem. I wanted the navy with rivets but couldn't order through boutique stores, ended up getting the navy with tea roses. Got home that same day and managed to score the navy with rivets through the outlet sale. Now I have two, with the same color (and also kind of considering the third due to them being discontinued). Here's my opinion, because it really depends on how you'd wear this bag. If you baby your bags, maybe the tea rose version is the one for you. The gunmetal hardware will get more visible wear and tear and personally I feel like I have to be careful with the tea roses. If you plan on wearing the bag a lot without wanting to worry about wear and tear, maybe the rivets is the bag for you. My bags with the brass hardware are a lot sturdier than the ones with gunmetal. Hope that helps 
So hard to decide!! Are you looking for a bag you will carry often or change out for special occasions? If they discontinue the rogue I feel a good staple piece would be worth the investment. I would go with the rivets, I think the tea rose might get tiring with it being busy. But go with the one you love ❤️
Good choice and congrats on getting the clochette too. It still looks like some black 25's have one and some don't. Tempted to reorder mine and see what arrives
Please post pics if you get beechwood! I was torn between it and chalk. I have no chalk in my collection so I went with it, but am still eyeing beechwood.
Thank you! I was super happy that it had the clochette. I got mine in store. I think it was the last black they had besides the display. I will definitely post pics! They put it on hold for him and it was the last they had in beechwood besides display as well. I’ve always thought the beechwood was gorgeous! Chalk is as well! ❤️Good choice and congrats on getting the clochette too. It still looks like some black 25's have one and some don't. Tempted to reorder mine and see what arrives
I have three bags with tea roses (Rogue 25 in Black/Oxblood and Washed Red, Dinky with Tea Roses) and they’re all wearing very well. I wouldn’t be afriad of tea roses at all, although the crystals versions would give me pause.
You can’t go wrong with a black Rogue - they’re beautiful.
You can’t go wrong with a black Rogue - they’re beautiful.