I actually think the pink might be easier to wear if you have a lot of different patterns/colors in your wardrobe. However the shearling version is puffy so looks larger than the leather version of the same size, so keep that in mind.
Omg! I thought I was the only one that wanted the shearling. I love it! It’s so fun and chic! Of course if you have a lot of classics already, this seems to be a very fun piece. It’s pretty sturdy but the bag I tried on was kind of heavy. It was the black medium shearling.