I think it depends on your skin tone. Warm undertone people look better with gold, as colder skin tone people do with silver. I have warm skin tone and I do think gold watched look better on me than silver ones. But my favourite everyday watch is a silver, because most of my jewellery are silver.
Silver one would be my choice. Most gold on gold tone watched tend to wear off in places on a watch that's worn on a daily basis & sometimes it will change in color tone. I like yellow, white or rose metals & do tend to mix them. Perhaps a two tone would work as others have suggested.