Which one should I get-swagger rivet crossbody or Edie Turnlock?

[couchette]

My anniversary is coming up and surprisingly I get to pick out a purse .Currenlty the swagger is on hold at Macy’s. I’m so in love with this one but I know the Edie Turnlock will be more practical. I currenlty have the Edie black western rivets purse, I love it. A few of the rivets on handle came off so concerned that’ll happen with the swagger too. I will be on a purse ban for quite awhile so I need to make the right decision.

 

[houseof999]

My anniversary is coming up and surprisingly I get to pick out a purse .Currenlty the swagger is on hold at Macy’s. I’m so in love with this one but I know the Edie Turnlock will be more practical. I currenlty have the Edie black western rivets purse, I love it. A few of the rivets on handle came off so concerned that’ll happen with the swagger too. I will be on a purse ban for quite awhile so I need to make the right decision.

I say the Edie since you already know it works for you. The Swagger won't nearly hold as much as the Edie either.

 

[Miraku]

Swagger!
You already have an Edie, time to try something new!

Plus Coach will replace the hardware if it falls off (within a year for free) so I wouldn't worry about the rivets. I have the rivet Swagger 27 and it's pristine.

 

[AstridRhapsody]

I vote Edie turnlock! I'm using my black/snakeskin one today for the first time and absolutely love it!
I'm typically more of a 1941 buyer but love how easy and comfortable this Edie is to use. I ordered the metallic graphite one from the Macy's sale and it should arrive tomorrow, hope I love it too.

 

[CoachMaven]

If you already have an Edie, my vote would be for the Swagger if that one makes your heart flutter. I own two bags with rivets and they are securely attached, don't be afraid that they will come off. If you are using the Swagger as a crossbody, being chalk white, I recommend using a protectant on the leather to prevent color transfer with denim. I use Apple Rain and Stain Guard spray for my Rogue satchel in chalk white, and it allows any transfer to come off easily with a baby wipe. Whichever you choose, they are both beautiful!

 

[CoachMaven]

Also wanted to add, if you had rivets fall off, how long ago did you purchase the bag? Because you can take it to any Coach store for them to send in for repairs.

 

[whateve]

The Swagger is too small for me. If you plan on using it as a special occasion bag, it might work for you. I have a few Coach bags with rivets and have never lost any.

 

[Winterfell5]

I would get the Edie turnlock, which holds a lot more than the Swagger.

 

[honybr]

I'm also team Edie. However I've had several bags with rivets and have never lost one.

 

[couchette]

Thanks so much all!Just got back from Macys and after looking at the Edie, wow the purse is gorgeous ! Looks so different than my black western river Edie so I bought it. And picked up this beauty marked down to $117 what a great find. I’ve always wanted a tote

 

[couchette]

 

[couchette]

I vote Edie turnlock! I'm using my black/snakeskin one today for the first time and absolutely love it!
I'm typically more of a 1941 buyer but love how easy and comfortable this Edie is to use. I ordered the metallic graphite one from the Macy's sale and it should arrive tomorrow, hope I love it too.

almost bought this beautiful metallic one today but vast majority of my purses are dark . Thinking I should go back and grab it for my sister

 

[couchette]

close up of the metallic one color is just amazing