I agree on the feel of it. If its really soft (like you can see it will start to droop quickly), then thats the one I keephow soft is the one you own now?
if it's soft i'd keep it. it's hard to tell from a photo which one is "better", because i've had dry-not-so-desirable bbags photography really well - so it's not always the best way to judge.
kim @ balny definitely picks out AMAZZZING bags!