Which makeup bag do you ladies prefer ?

jamiet

Member
Sep 19, 2009
325
0
I am trying to decide between the smaller size makeup bag or the toiletry 19 bag. I have never really paid attention to these in the store so I'm trying to compare between the two sizes and what all fits in them.
 

YOGAGIRL70

Member
Sep 28, 2012
4,437
612
Chicago
I am trying to decide between the smaller size makeup bag or the toiletry 19 bag. I have never really paid attention to these in the store so I'm trying to compare between the two sizes and what all fits in them.
The GM cosmetic will fit about the same amount as the TP 19... if you get the small cosmetic pouch it will hold less than the TP 19. Ultimately, I ended up with the PM and GM cosmetic cases ~ I use them in different bags. I had the TP 19 and over time, decided I just did not care for the looks of it as much as the regular cosmetic pouch. HTH! :smile:
 

Oryx816

H-eureuse
Apr 30, 2014
4,362
2,404
The GM cosmetic will fit about the same amount as the TP 19... if you get the small cosmetic pouch it will hold less than the TP 19. Ultimately, I ended up with the PM and GM cosmetic cases ~ I use them in different bags. I had the TP 19 and over time, decided I just did not care for the looks of it as much as the regular cosmetic pouch. HTH! :smile:

Same here! I also use the DE PM and GM. I like the feminine look so much more. You have to practice a little to pack them just right and not get the wavy zipper effect but in the end they are great! They put a smile on my face each time I take them out! I have received many a ladies' room compliment on them! :smile:
 

Prettyn

Member
Dec 9, 2013
1,150
97
LOUIS VUITTON Brown Monogram Canvas Toiletry Cosmetic Bag , size 28. It is an old one I bought from Japan and love it! It holds so much and I put it in My DE NF MM.
 

JadaStormy

Member
Jan 23, 2012
5,073
2,349
houstatlantavegas
I am trying to decide between the smaller size makeup bag or the toiletry 19 bag. I have never really paid attention to these in the store so I'm trying to compare between the two sizes and what all fits in them.
You should check for videos on youtube. I had both and I prefer the TP 19. The cosmetic bag is more feminine, however if you fill it more than half way it can get all wonky and it won't close smoothly because of the half moon shape.
 

LVk8

Me + Harpua
Jan 30, 2014
2,082
362
In The VeLVet Sea
I don't have either but I would someday buy a TP 19 bc I like that it's tall enough for products that are best standing up rather than laying sideways. But I do prefer that the cosmetic bag comes in all the colors of the rainbow ❤️
 

Louisgyal37

Member
Feb 3, 2013
2,858
4,063
Lawrenceville, GA
I have all 3 TP sizes, cosmetic pm in mc, and had but sold a cosmetic gm de. Trial and error but I prefer the TP 19 due to size, slim shape fits well into medium sized bags. The cosmetic GM is lovely and fits alot but takes up too much room unless you have a large sized bag like the NF GM. Even in my artsy, it felt too big and accommodated the TP 26 better. It all depends on quantity of items in the cosmetic bag and size of your bags in general...GLD!!
 

LValicious

Member
Aug 28, 2013
1,018
64
I am trying to decide between the smaller size makeup bag or the toiletry 19 bag. I have never really paid attention to these in the store so I'm trying to compare between the two sizes and what all fits in them.

Tp19 to me is most useful. I have the smaller de cosmetic case and it doesn't seem to hold much. I've kept it because it's so cute I'm afraid if I get rid of it I will be sorry. HTH :smile:
 

designer1

Member
Jul 23, 2010
1,632
449
CANADA
I don't have either but I would someday buy a TP 19 bc I like that it's tall enough for products that are best standing up rather than laying sideways. But I do prefer that the cosmetic bag comes in all the colors of the rainbow ❤️
This is why I love this beauty, bottles stay upright, and lots of room for other stuff! Its a vanity case, but I use it as a handbag, and will throw some makeup and skincare in it when I travel for the weekend! :smile:
 

Attachments

K.H.LVoe

Handbag Heaven
Sep 21, 2012
1,458
80
I just got the mono cosmetic PM and it works beautifully for me. Wouldn't want a larger one to take up more space in my bags.
 

LValicious

Member
Aug 28, 2013
1,018
64
I just got the mono cosmetic PM and it works beautifully for me. Wouldn't want a larger one to take up more space in my bags.

Can you post a pic of what u carry in it and if there is a certain way u put things in if you don't mind :smile:
 

MelanieJoyce

Member
Jul 14, 2012
2,363
12
Texas <3
I actually asked everyone here in TPF the same question a couple months ago and ended up with the cosmetic pm. I don't regret it one bit! It's a beautiful little bag and much more aesthetically pleasing than the TP19. :heart: