I would pick the first one as well for reason mentioned above.
But you have a LV bag in your avatar, why not a key pouch in Louis Vuitton? Or something limited edition? Hahaha. Just enabling here.
I kind of like all my SLGs to match. I've picked Louis Vuitton monogram mainly. But say if I get a Chanel bag, I also pick up a small wallet in the same color. Same with Bottega Veneta and other brands.