Which jacket to get?? I need your opinions!!!

I would get the jacket that you just can't get out of your head - and that has the 'wow' factor. SOme things you try on just meld into your being.... Others just sit on top.

The following jacket (Diesel Tegugia Jacket - on sale from Tobi's for $161) reminds me of a combination of all three of your picks. Not sure why but it immediately popped into my head when I saw your photos and I do think this jacket is very, very cute... just a thought though... :girlsigh:
Love that! The first is the most versatile of all three. I do think it is a bit shapeless on the model, perhaps it's too large on her? Hm, I like two and three as well but I feel they're a bit thick to be worn across seasons (late fall/winter only).