Which is better for 10th anniversary gift?

[Redd]

Hi all... I just saw these rings on Tiffany.com and love both. I liked the iolite because I love purple and think the ring is so gorgeous. Then I saw the diamond one and had second thoughts. My wedding band is 14k gold with diamonds- on the top only. This one is white gold with diamonds all around, but still not sure if it's too similar. The iolite one is so different. Thoughts? Thanks!

http://www.tiffany.com/Shopping/Ite...+1-p+1-c+-r+-x+-n+6-ri+-ni+0-t+metro&search=1

http://www.tiffany.com/Shopping/Ite...+1-p+1-c+-r+-x+-n+6-ri+-ni+0-t+metro&search=1

 

[I'll take 2]

I love the iolite. But both are lovely.

 

[ceya]

of course, diamond is forever.

 

[lily25]

The first one, metro ring!!! I'm crazy about it! Happy anniversary!

 

[Golden Touch]

Congrats on your "wedded bliss mile stone"!

If you love purple then you should get the Iolite ring - it is a pretty colour. I "personally" don't wear much colour so I would choose the diamonds.

 

[ayla]

Diamonds !!!

 

[ETenebris]

I love the diamond band. I think if you get the iolite you should get two and wear one on each side of your wedding rings.

 

[bagladyseattle]

i love the diamond one.

 

[Redd]

Thanks so much to all that posted- this is a toughie! All decisions should be so hard, huh?

 

[candypants1100]

i love both of them. if you love the purple, then you will definitely wear it, so i'd go for that one if i were you.

 

[True*Fidelity]

Diamond.

This ring plus your wedding band, combined, will dazzle all eyes.

 

[barcreperie]

Redd, have you seen these Metro rings 'in person'? I also fell in love with them on the website, and when I went to the store to try them on I was very disappointed. They are very thin, very flat, and have almost no presence at all. I tried them on with a couple of Celebration rings I own, and it was a definite no-go. The Metro ring got lost in my other rings. Even the saleswoman said it was a no-go. I tried stacking 2-3 of them in different colors to see if that would make them more attractive, but it didn't. I was very unimpressed with these rings.