Which ID Holder?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

JVSXOXO

JVSXOXO

Lover of leather 😍
Feb 16, 2017
1,189
7,823
#1
So I’ve put myself on Ban Island after buying two Rogue Totes but I figured a couple small purchases never hurt anybody! I started a new job about a month ago and now need to carry keys on me whenever I step foot out of my personal office due to it being on a large, open floor. So I have 3 keys - one for my office door, one for the kitchen, and a small one for my mailbox. To get into our copy room and conference rooms, I have swipe card access. They’re usually already propped open when I get to work but sometimes the front office staff closes them early before I leave, so it’s best to just carry my keys and ID card on me. I want something cute and I’m trying to decide between these options. The Kate Spade doesn’t have the best reviews and is made of silicone instead of leather, so I likely won’t get it, but I just love the polka dots. Which would you go for?

B894B255-A417-4833-8962-DD294E56D414.jpeg 06452ACB-360E-48EE-9458-DD29C7E255CC.jpeg 30303C76-0E46-435C-86C0-DF0FCAC2DB07.jpeg 21ADA4C4-0C31-483E-A523-0BDE7AC81AD3.jpeg 5841B0B7-7272-4A00-A9DD-09FD5573DD5F.jpeg 7A13F96B-21C1-4CC1-A605-AE0F272986BE.jpeg
 
#2
I would get the Coach simply due to the lanyard. You can keep it around your neck or looped around your purse for convenience and security. And since you’re using it for keys, it’s important to keep them close to you so the lanyard is a great option to have.

The KS one is adorable, but I don’t like that it only comes with a clip. Just my personal preference. Best of luck with your decision.
 
  • Like
Reactions: amateurjeweler, IntheOcean, Tosa22 and 1 other person
#3
anthrosphere said:
I would get the Coach simply due to the lanyard. You can keep it around your neck or looped around your purse for convenience and security. And since you’re using it for keys, it’s important to keep them close to you so the lanyard is a great option to have.

The KS one is adorable, but I don’t like that it only comes with a clip. Just my personal preference. Best of luck with your decision.
Click to expand...

I do like that the Coach options come with a lanyard. I didn’t mind the KS not having one because I already have a lanyard that I carry my keys on so I could attach it. But I do think the Coach options look a little more refined while KS is more fun.
 
#5
Tomsmom said:
I like the coach ones
Click to expand...
Me too, I think I'm definitely going to go with one of the Coach ones over KS. There are also North/South style ones. My ID card is East/West but it really doesn't matter since I just need it on me to swipe. I think I like the look of these better...

Coach ID Card Case NS.jpg Coach ID Case NS Floral.jpg

Now I just need to decide if I want plain black or something that stands out a little.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tomsmom
#6
JVSXOXO said:
Me too, I think I'm definitely going to go with one of the Coach ones over KS. There are also North/South style ones. My ID card is East/West but it really doesn't matter since I just need it on me to swipe. I think I like the look of these better...

View attachment 4476117 View attachment 4476118

Now I just need to decide if I want plain black or something that stands out a little.
Click to expand...

I like the brown one you posted with the flower it stands out .
 
  • Like
Reactions: TangerineKandy and JVSXOXO
#9
There is another Coach one that I really like because it fits a ton, it's in Men Department, I think. it can be opened like wallet, and there's a button to snap it shut. I think it is only available in grey monogram? I put money, debit and credit card there, and I can just take it and ny phone for lunch
 
  • Like
Reactions: JVSXOXO
#10
floodette said:
There is another Coach one that I really like because it fits a ton, it's in Men Department, I think. it can be opened like wallet, and there's a button to snap it shut. I think it is only available in grey monogram? I put money, debit and credit card there, and I can just take it and ny phone for lunch
Click to expand...

That sounds very useful, but a little bigger than what I had in mind. I love my Mini Skinny ID case though and don't think I'll ever go back to a full sized wallet anytime soon!

Coach ID Card Case NS.jpg

I was boring and ended up going with this one. It arrived today and it's perfect! I won't be back to work until Monday but I look forward to using it then :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Georgiaseven
#11
JVSXOXO said:
That sounds very useful, but a little bigger than what I had in mind. I love my Mini Skinny ID case though and don't think I'll ever go back to a full sized wallet anytime soon!

View attachment 4480185

I was boring and ended up going with this one. It arrived today and it's perfect! I won't be back to work until Monday but I look forward to using it then :smile:
Click to expand...
You could always get it personalized with Coach create.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top