Trying to decide between these 3. They haven't listed the size for Picasso's but I assume they're all the same size. Open to other options under $1,500
Which Heart Pendant should I get?
- Thread starter Ash2019
- Start date
TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
I like the #3, but I have a feeling this maybe the unpopular opinion.
I vote for Elsa Peretti heartTrying to decide between these 3. They haven't listed the size for Picasso's but I assume they're all the same size. Open to other options under $1,500
My view of the three choices mentioned is:-
1. Classic and timeless.
2. Awkward shape.
3. More of a statement with an interesting mix of curves and angles.
Your choice will depend upon the occasions you'd like to wear it, I think.
1. Classic and timeless.
2. Awkward shape.
3. More of a statement with an interesting mix of curves and angles.
Your choice will depend upon the occasions you'd like to wear it, I think.
Adding a poll with pictures would solicit more responses.
I think open heart is more iconic, so that would usually be my pick. But I would prefer all gold, so my pick is 2 or 3.
2 might present better, since I think it’s a bit larger overall with less details. But 3 has some fun design elements and maybe is a bit wider? Between those two, I don’t know the scale, but I would pick the “bigger” one.
I think open heart is more iconic, so that would usually be my pick. But I would prefer all gold, so my pick is 2 or 3.
2 might present better, since I think it’s a bit larger overall with less details. But 3 has some fun design elements and maybe is a bit wider? Between those two, I don’t know the scale, but I would pick the “bigger” one.
I don't see poll as an option, maybe because my account is relatively new, but like you said 2 is slightly bigger than 3. I like the design on 1 but also prefer full gold.
Picasso loving heart is .58" in height and .46" wide.
Heart and Arrow is .5620' in height and .4500 wide
How about this Elsa Peretti necklace? It's yellow gold with some diamonds for $1400. It also comes in rose gold.
It's not too small you think?
It's 11mm wide, gold and silver one is 16mm.
It depends on what you are looking for. For me, I don't think so, and I would find it easy to wear. I have the larger Elsa Peretti Heart in YG and I find it a bit large.
I’m actually so shocked that they are all similar in price, yet the majority of the two-tone open heart pendant is made out of sterling silver?! Am I reading that right? It seems like your dollar would go farther with the solid YG/RG in option 2 (loving heart) or 3 (graffiti arrow) Between the two, I like how the simplicity of loving heart can be dressed up or down. The arrow motif is unique and edgy and I think would stack nicely with other necklaces, but I tend to prefer simpler if I had to wear a singular necklace.
Correct the first one is mostly silver. The gold version is $2,700.
since this is gift not for me, do you think something like this would be more presentable? Elsa peretti has a similar design for $8K.
Sabel 14K White Gold Open Heart Diamond Pendant
A lovely Valentine's Day gift for the one you adore, our diamond heart pendant features an open heart, 18" chain and diamonds. Shop pendants now.
