First one! I think the first one is more edgy and I love caviar boy, the second one for me personally a little bit too busy and too shiny. The most important thing is which one do you like more? What one suits your style better?
I would say the first one, but the photos are in different scenarios. The first one is in a home setting, on a chair or couch, while the second one is professionally lit from the website. It may be toned down in real life.
In the minority, I like the second one! I saw a YouTube video of it a few months back and fell in love! I did end up going for the same boy but in black though.