That's a toughie! I have a Boogie and a French Nanny and I love them *almost* equally. My French Nanny just slightly edges out the Boogie. I personally prefer the slightly longer strap drop and the less structured shape, plus I'm a light packer so I very rarely have enough to fill up my Boogie and it ends up being tough to find things even with a purse organizer. BUT, I prefer the magnetic snap closure on the Boogie and it looks very chic. It's a hard decision! No matter what bag you decide on, you absolutely can't miss with the grape leather! It's so unbelievably gorgeous, not to mention versatile!