Definitely Legacy. Although I was a little disappointed that my Large Bleecker Flap bag didn't have the tattersall lining. I do like the tattersall better than plain!
The Tattersall print is really what brought me to Coach. It has that classic feel. I even wanted the Bleecker duffle and I hate how it looks just so I can have the lining. LOL
I like Tattersall, but I love love love love love love love love love love love love love love love love love love love love love love love love love love love Legacy!
I love both and have bags with both linings (Bleecker Duffle & 2 Ali's), but every single time I open my legacy bags, that lining just knocks me out. It's SO beautiful. So, out of the two, I must pick legacy as my fav!