which do you like better?

OH might be more comfy on the shoulder but looks like a pain to access-small concave opening-I picture struggling with a zipper-unless its a magnetic closure which would make life easier. JC is more versatile in carrying options and not as generic looking as the OH-a little more stylish IMO.
 
They are both very nice but I prefer the Olivia because you could wear it on your shoulder or hand carry it depending on your mood. Even though the Rhodie has a shoulder strap as well, I wouldn't wear it as a shoulder bag because the style doesn't fit that use(IMO) and it wouldn't be as comfortable that way either. I'm usually not that picky about handbags but since I like both of these I had to be picky about something to choose one!:P