Which Carla Mancini bag should I get?

[shopaholic2]

Hi Ladies,

I need your opinions. I want to get one of these clutch, but I just don't know which print I should get. I don't plan to wear it as a clutch though (can't stand clutch). I plan to wear it as a shoulder bag. They're both the same shape essentially.

One is the black quilted leather -- classy looking; would go with formal wear; but does it look like an imitation Chanel?

The other one is a gray/white pattern with brown stitching -- it is also leather; it seems more fun to me; is it too crazy though? is it wearable? can I wear it with much?

What are your opinions?

 

[BgaHolic]

Out of the two, I would go with the black one and no, it does not look like a Chanel.

 

[alouette]

I like the fun pattern. The black and quilted pattern are more classic and elegant though. If you're going for the latter, then #1. If you want something more spunky, #2. I voted for the second btw.

 

[DiorDeVille]

I like the gray one better, but it does look far more casual and less formal in the pictures.

 

[IrisCole]

I think I like the black just a pinch better, but it kind of depends on what you're looking to use it for.

 

[Catdance]

I like the black, it's lovely!

 

[DisCo]

I would go for the black quilted one

 

[kateincali]

I voted for the quilted black leather. It doesn't look anything like Chanel to me, though, personally.