Hmmm this is a tough one. I see the western vibe of the Chloe pair, which I don't like, but then I agree with the others that the suede pair might be a pain to keep clean. I'm going to go w/ the minority and say keep looking b/c it does not seem you love either since you are questioning both pairs. When you are spending that much on a pair of shoes, you should definitely LOVE them right?