This! The butterfly totem bag and tiger print are beautiful and one of a kind.If you have to return one I would do one of the two Padlocks, as they are too similar. Of the two, I prefer the tiger one. Normally I love the GG print in blue, but that combination of colors in the last Padlock doesn't work for me.
That way you end up with three very different bags. Not everybody can carry the butterfly totem, but if you see yourself, it is a stunner.