Have you also considered the boot charm in rouge H that has the orange H boxes in the boot? Or even the rouge H Ox? Or perhaps the black and white panda charm for contrast?
I used to have the bear, the dog and the owl charms (all of which have gone to lovely new homes)...of all 3, the best with my rouge h lindy was the owl, because the dog and the bear do not have much contrast to the bag like the owl ..... i think i have a pic of my rouge h lindy with the dog charm, if I find it, I will post it here for you =)
oops I voted Tiger before I read your post, I had the red tiger on my mind!! I personally think that the red tiger would look better than orange tiger or even last year's red cow?