I went with classic and got YG. Most of my jewelry is actually white gold and sterling silver and I'm super fair skinned with cool tones so typically white gold and silver compliment my skin tone better. However, since the plain WG love wasn't rhodium plated, I didn't care for the stainless steel shade of their WG. I also looked at countless photos on here to see how the various colors looked over time and determined that the YG and RG retained more of a shine as they developed their patina as opposed to WG which took on even more of a stainless steel/matte appearance (IMO). I'm not a fan of RG so that easily narrowed it down to the YG for me and I have never regretted the decision. It's timeless.