Hi
rainbow_rose and
welcome!
Unfortunately, I don't think it would be responsible for me to recommend either type of bag, on the basis that it will 'still look really stylish' in the long term. If you want a bag that will not go out of fashion, so quickly; you really need to choose a more unusual designer, or style, so that most people don't know what it is and/or which season/era it's from!
IMO, both of these beautiful bags are, almost certainly, way too recognisable to escape the shifting sands of fashion, for too much longer (I've already heard quite a few murmurings of 'I think I may be over the whole padlock thing/Spy thing', on this forum :worried: ).
If you like these bags, buy the one you like the best and enjoy it, but please don't expect it to stay in fashion for ever!
I think both bags have an equal chance of lasting (i.e. not falling apart), if you take good care of them.
Hope this helps!
