If I get to the point where I'm asking TPF keep or return, this usually means I'm unsure and end up returning...just did that with SGH Magenta (and a few others)! So...moral to the story even if the bag is beautiful - go with your gut!!!
I got a 2007 black city but was having second thoughts so I got the 2008, and I love it!
Like everyone else said if youre having second thoughts, return it
Mine is a F/W also and as of now is jet black as you can see in the pics but i am still worried about fading i think im going to keep it because i have already fallen in love with it