my house just closed last week, hooray... sold and done. one, i did not do a cleaning before leaving because you don't have to. that's not a law anywhere. the house was spotless, but still... there is no requirement for a seller to clean up for the buyer. when you initially toured the home you should have asked for cleaning or whatever on the contract, or your agent should have advised you to do so, or to ask for new carpeting. if it's not in the contract the seller is under no obligation to do any cleaning. did you have a home inspection done? if so, that would have been another opportunity to see what is wrong with the house and what you wanted fixed. your final walkthrough is when you have the chance to make sure the home is in the same condition as when you first saw it, and to check on any repairs that were done. sellers are usually advised to not touch anything in the home once an offer is accepted (except to have items repaired) b/c a buyer wants the home in the condition they initially saw it in. if you saw the carpet that way and then made the offer and didn't ask for new carpet, then how is that the realtor's fault. they are there to advise you but when buying a property you have to look out for yourself and know something of what you're doing. lesson learned for next time, right? just clean your new place and move on. the realtor seems kinda nasty but not sure she did anything wrong.