First one, I would have this one also if it was included in PCE!! Darnit. I'm really not in the market for a bag at the moment (incase you haven't heard I'm totally in love with my black/silver carly,lol) but maybe Christmas will bring me it. I have a awhile to decide on the color.
I really like them both. I shy away from suede because of the upkeep, but having the patent back on these styles totally solves the problem of color transfer onto the back and the rubbingcausing the suede to lose its nap. The shoulder is cute but too small for me, so I would go with the tote.