The metallic paddingtons are edgy, and I personally find the black paddington with the black hardware to look very rock chic like.
The bettys are softer imo, not as edgy, and the Edith are much more a work staple bag, although do look good dressed down with jeans.
I would go with the new bay its brand new out, and the quilted version will be released in the next few weeks and is a stunner imo. Picture of the new bay here, and it is also available in creme, black and brown
Go to Intemix.com and check out their chain handled Betty's.......they are edgy. I have the small version and by far it's my most favorite purse of all time. Very rocker babe sophisticated. Plus this retailer is selling them >50% off.
Call the Intermix store in NY and see what they have on the floor for other deals.
I have the black/black paddy and it can be edgy and versatile.
I also have the Black Chain Betty Tote. I feel like the chain betty is edgier, just really cool yet, clean lined classic.
I had a great "very pristine" man stop me in baggage claim this weekend to comment how much he liked my Betty Tote. He told me he had one too!!!!!
out of all the chloe styles, I think the paddy is the most edgy... it really adds the extra to any casual outfit. I really like the quilted bay bags though too..
I have a silvery dark metallic python silverado that is really edgy. (So edgy that I have worn it exactly twice.)
I think metallic paddies are everyday wear-able edgy. Agree that chain bettys are too. The python betty that Kate Moss rocks is pretty darn edgy too. LOVE that bag!