That's a great style but on the high end for a used Tano. Depends upon the condition since "EUC" seems to be rather subjective, and how much you love the bag.
I'm sorry but how in the BLUE HELL do you justify a price of $99 as the "high end" of anything except maybe dinner for one? EDIT: Tano's may not carry the HUGE resale other brands of bags carry but $99.... for a well made Tano... that's chump change for such a good bag.
Tori: Since I haven't seen the pics of the bag if you feel in your judgement the bag is in EUC then I, personally, would buy it. VVGG's don't just pop up every day.
I think you got robbed Sybaryte if you sold your for $51..... if you bought one for that price good for you!