Violet Dakotah, Mink Rhyder or Saddle embossed Edie?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

N

nanrao

O.G.
May 3, 2006
408
23
#1
With a few hours left to go, what should I do? I already have the small black and blue dakotah, as well as the 28 in red currant. Love love love the style, works so well for me. But is a fourth one too many?? Love the shade of purple/violet too.

The Rhyder - I will use this only as a cross body and not as a satchel. Love it for that. But it really is not a me bag - I'm usually a hobo girl. But I love the color and the style of this so....

The Edie - I never was a fan of the Phoebe - tried a few times to like it, but returned them all. I like the straps of the Edie better, but the bag is essentially similar to the Phoebe, so will the same things that I did not like with P bother me with E?

I know the choice is ultimately mine, but figured asking around might not hurt. Thanks in advance for all your words of wisdom ladies!
 
#2
I just ordered Dakota 28 in red currant so violet Dakota gets my vote! 4 is not too many! Not if it'd the style that works for you! You know what works and what doesn't and you'll be happier with the violet D vs. Anything else! Also the leather is awesome on the Dakota and I really don't like the rhyder leather! :) jmo!
 
#4
I think you should go with what you like and what works for you, so my vote is for the Dakotah. I was never a fan of multiples until I found one that worked for me.
 
#9
4 isn't too much, but I like to try different styles, I only have 2 sets of 2 Multiples(if that makes sense? ) other than that , I try to branch out! But that's just me! Go with your gut! All are great choices anyway! ;)
 
#10
Thanks everyone! I went ahead and ordered the purple Dakotah. I just love everything about this bag in both sizes. If I don't get another bag at all, I would be ok, that is how much I love this bag. So so classic.
 
#11
nanrao said:
Thanks everyone! I went ahead and ordered the purple Dakotah. I just love everything about this bag in both sizes. If I don't get another bag at all, I would be ok, that is how much I love this bag. So so classic.
Click to expand...


:D
Post pics when it arrives! This was going to be my vote. She looks gorgeous! Congrats!
 
#13
If you don't like Phoebe, do not buy Edie. It's the exact same architecture, different leather. You will not be happy with it.

Get the Dakotah. Such a great looking bag, and if you like a shoulder bag like that - well, then get it b/c it's fantastic :)
 
#14
shminbabe said:
If you don't like Phoebe, do not buy Edie. It's the exact same architecture, different leather. You will not be happy with it.

Get the Dakotah. Such a great looking bag, and if you like a shoulder bag like that - well, then get it b/c it's fantastic :)
Click to expand...

And…I should have read the to end of the thread! Oh well. You got the Dakotah! Can't wait to see it. Post pics when you can!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top